香港滑雪論壇

香港滑雪論壇 (http://www.hkssa.net/index.php)
-   滑雪綜合討論 (http://www.hkssa.net/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   講雪質同量, 是不是NISEKO會比WHISTLER優勝? (http://www.hkssa.net/showthread.php?t=64935)

Petersoo 2017-09-04 14:19

講雪質同量, 是不是NISEKO會比WHISTLER優勝?
 
如題, thx

Mike 2017-09-04 17:24

For reference: http://hkssa.net/showthread.php?t=60379

Personally, I think it is more than 雪質 & 量, the mountain is also a very important factor to consider. For me, the mountain is the most important factor.

wowmac 2017-09-04 17:55

Mike is right !
It's depends.

My experience:
For on-piste, Whistler, really great than Niseko.
For off-piste, includes sidecountry, backcountry, Niseko.
For getting more snow, Niseko, for example only one week vacation.
Snow Quality, fresh powder, I think, same same. But they said, 4% water content at Hokkaido, 6-7% at Utah, 16-20% at Whistler. So, if after one day, there is big difference.

Food, Onsen, no doubt, Niseko.

Petersoo 2017-09-04 20:55

引用:

作者: Mike (文章 90703)
For reference: http://hkssa.net/showthread.php?t=60379

Personally, I think it is more than 雪質 & 量, the mountain is also a very important factor to consider. For me, the mountain is the most important factor.

Quoted from the above link:

Here is a comparison with what I paid or going to pay for skiing in USA this coming season:
4* Hotel (not Lodge type) accommodation = US$70 per room per night.
Lift ticket = US$369 for season pass (otherwise varies between US$60 & US$88 per day)
Lunch in mountain restaurant = about US10
Buffet dinner in casino = US$15 per person

Which resort and hotel are you reference to? Thanks.

Mike 2017-09-05 08:07

引用:

作者: Petersoo (文章 90705)
Quoted from the above link:

Which resort and hotel are you reference to? Thanks.

Please note that thread was 6 years old. Price have changed.

Petersoo 2017-09-05 09:54

引用:

作者: Mike (文章 90707)
Please note that thread was 6 years old. Price have changed.

I know. Just want to find some high CP ski resort in the world. Any recommendation now?:kiss:

Mike 2017-09-05 11:10

引用:

作者: Petersoo (文章 90708)
I know. Just want to find some high CP ski resort in the world. Any recommendation now?:kiss:

Below is a list of some of the ski resorts that I have been and my personal preference (bear in mind quality of skiing and the mountain are the important factors):

Ski resorts that I recommend:
USA: Deer Valley, Alta, Snowbird, Sundance; Beaver Creek; Keystone; Vail; Heavenly; Squaw Valley; Mammouth; Aspen
Alps: Verbier; Zermatt; Wengen; Val d’isere; Tignes; Trois Valees; Chamonix; Megeve; Dolomites; Les Arcs; Champoluc; Lech; Cervinia
Southern Hemisphere: Portillo; Valle Nevado

Resorts that are OK:
USA: Sugar Bowl; Northstar; Kirkwood; Alpine Meadows; Homewood; Whistler; Araphoe Basin; Breckenridge; Snowbasin; Park City; Mt Rose;
Alps: Avoriaz; Bormio; Courmayeur; Flaine; Les Deux Alps; Les Gets; Morzine; La Plagne; Pila; Ischgl; Galtur
Southern Hemisphere: Whakapapa; Coronet Peak; Treble Cone; Remarkable

Resorts that I do not like:
Southern Hemisphere: Perisher; Thredbo; Mt Hutt; Cardrona
Korea: Yongpyong
Japan: Naeba; Shiga Kogen; Niseko; Rusutsu; Kiroro

Petersoo 2017-09-05 14:11

引用:

作者: Mike (文章 90709)
Below is a list of some of the ski resorts that I have been and my personal preference (bear in mind quality of skiing and the mountain are the important factors):

Ski resorts that I recommend:
USA: Deer Valley, Alta, Snowbird, Sundance; Beaver Creek; Keystone; Vail; Heavenly; Squaw Valley; Mammouth; Aspen
Alps: Verbier; Zermatt; Wengen; Val d’isere; Tignes; Trois Valees; Chamonix; Megeve; Dolomites; Les Arcs; Champoluc; Lech; Cervinia
Southern Hemisphere: Portillo; Valle Nevado

Resorts that are OK:
USA: Sugar Bowl; Northstar; Kirkwood; Alpine Meadows; Homewood; Whistler; Araphoe Basin; Breckenridge; Snowbasin; Park City; Mt Rose;
Alps: Avoriaz; Bormio; Courmayeur; Flaine; Les Deux Alps; Les Gets; Morzine; La Plagne; Pila; Ischgl; Galtur
Southern Hemisphere: Whakapapa; Coronet Peak; Treble Cone; Remarkable

Resorts that I do not like:
Southern Hemisphere: Perisher; Thredbo; Mt Hutt; Cardrona
Korea: Yongpyong
Japan: Naeba; Shiga Kogen; Niseko; Rusutsu; Kiroro

Thanks for the valuable informtion.

Surprised to hear that some most popular ski resort in Japan that you don't like it. What are the reason?

Mike 2017-09-05 14:27

引用:

作者: Petersoo (文章 90712)
Thanks for the valuable informtion.

Surprised to hear that some most popular ski resort in Japan that you don't like it. What are the reason?

Too small, little variation, runs too short. Get bored after 2 days.

Been to Whistler 3 time, it is OK, but I would not want to go again, found it un-interesting.

Petersoo 2017-09-06 21:04

Amoung the USA ski resort you recommended, which ones are cheaper in terms of accomodation and ski pass?

Mike 2017-09-07 07:53

引用:

作者: Petersoo (文章 90741)
Amoung the USA ski resort you recommended, which ones are cheaper in terms of accomodation and ski pass?

Last time I went skiing in USA was 4 years ago, so I do not have the latest prices and have not made any comparison recently. Resorts like Vail, Aspen, Beaver Creek etc all have pricey hotels.
The Utah resorts are close to Salt Lake City and people usually stay in Salt Lake City and drive (or take buses) to the ski resorts daily. There should be some good hotel deals if you search around.
South Lake Tahoe in California is fairly reasonable with hotel prices, Harrahs is a good starting point. If you are willing to drive, the casinos in Reno are fairly cheap to stay. The daily ski pass is pricey but you can buy a Tahoe Value season pass for few hundred US dollars if you are prepared to buy few months before the ski season starts.

In general, depends on how long you are going for, the season pass is better value than the day passes . There are all types of deals, you just have to do some research. You can get some useful info by going through some of the previous threads in this website.

If you are driving, staying in a hotel/motel further out is cheaper than staying in a hotel next to the ski lifts. Convenience often comes at a high price.

KYL 2017-09-13 12:48

引用:

作者: Mike (文章 90744)
Last time I went skiing in USA was 4 years ago, so I do not have the latest prices and have not made any comparison recently. Resorts like Vail, Aspen, Beaver Creek etc all have pricey hotels.
The Utah resorts are close to Salt Lake City and people usually stay in Salt Lake City and drive (or take buses) to the ski resorts daily. There should be some good hotel deals if you search around.
South Lake Tahoe in California is fairly reasonable with hotel prices, Harrahs is a good starting point. If you are willing to drive, the casinos in Reno are fairly cheap to stay. The daily ski pass is pricey but you can buy a Tahoe Value season pass for few hundred US dollars if you are prepared to buy few months before the ski season starts.

In general, depends on how long you are going for, the season pass is better value than the day passes . There are all types of deals, you just have to do some research. You can get some useful info by going through some of the previous threads in this website.

If you are driving, staying in a hotel/motel further out is cheaper than staying in a hotel next to the ski lifts. Convenience often comes at a high price.

If I may add...

Tahoe has the same issues as Whistler - the snow is heavy and wet. They call it 'sierra cement'. Mammoth on the back side of the mountain range has much nicer snow.

SLC is a good deal if you stay in town, but you risk missing out on the best days - when it really dumps - the road from town closes! Meaning had you stayed on the mountain you could have had the mountain to yourself!

Petersoo 2017-09-19 14:09

Thanks for the advices.

Anyone knows if the lift pass of Whistler included the peak to peak lift?

edngwk 2017-09-20 14:25

引用:

作者: Petersoo (文章 90766)
Thanks for the advices.

Anyone knows if the lift pass of Whistler included the peak to peak lift?

Yes, ski lift ticket include peak to peak gondola

andy2667 2017-11-01 14:41

For Value for Money skiing resort/holidays, I think you can consider the ClubMed packages to the skiing area of the Alps.

The prices for those Three Tridant resorts such as Les Arc, La Plange Aime are very good.


所有時間均為香港時間。現在的時間是 07:43

Hong Kong Snowboard & Ski Association
Copyright © 2003 - 2018